Meaning of “The Moon Will Sing” by The Crane Wives

Written By Michael Miller

Michael is a music teacher and professional cellist. He loves uncovering the deeper meaning of popular songs.

“The Moon Will Sing” by The Crane Wives is a song that appears to dwell on themes of self-identity, choice, and relational dynamics, particularly a sense of loss and relinquishment of self. The narrator could have been “anyone,” but someone made a choice for them, altering their path and identity. The song seemingly touches on a relationship where the narrator feels overshadowed and diminished, shining only with the light given by another. It’s a narrative of love and loss, choice, and consequence. The moon metaphorically sings a song, possibly symbolizing a constant, unseen, but felt presence that observes and mourns the narrator’s struggles.

This song seems to be an exploration of self in relation to others and a reflection on decisions made and their enduring impacts.

Read on to dive deeper into the song’s rich tapestry of meaning, exploring themes of identity, love, and self-discovery, and discover what really makes the moon sing.

“The Moon Will Sing” Lyrics Meaning

Analyzing this piece chronologically, we start with a sense of lost potential and an identity shaped, or perhaps misshaped, by another, “I could have been anyone, anyone else/Before you made the choice for me.” These lines evoke a contemplation of fate and destiny, and a lamentation of a path not taken.

Continuing on, “My feet knew the path/We walked in the dark, in the dark,” signals a journey, a shared experience enveloped in uncertainty and lack of clarity, possibly reflecting emotional darkness or lack of enlightenment and understanding within a relationship.

The next segment, “All those empty rooms/We could have been anywhere, anywhere else/Instead I made a bed with apathy,” brings forth imagery of empty spaces, of possibilities unexplored, and decisions, or the lack thereof, impacting the current state of being. The admission of bedding with apathy reveals a resignation to the circumstances, a settling, and an acceptance of the mundane or the unfulfilling.

With the chorus, “The moon will sing a song for me/I loved you like the sun,” we witness a celestial duality representing the narrator’s emotional state. The moon, often symbolizing mystery, the unseen, and the emotional, sings for the narrator, potentially echoing their unspoken pains and sorrows. In contrast, the sun represents warmth, life, and visibility, illuminating the shadows in the relationship and reflecting a love that is vibrant and giving.

The reiteration, “I shine only with the light you gave me,” emphasizes a reliance on the other person for illumination, for identity, for existence. It resonates with a loss of individuality and a sense of being overshadowed by the other’s essence, only shining, or existing meaningfully, through the other’s light or perception.

Towards the end, “Name your courage now/We could have had anything, anything else/Instead you hoarded all that’s left of me,” the song narrates a moment of confrontation, a demand for acknowledgment and realization of the could-have-beens, and a sense of being consumed and left empty by the other.

The concluding lines, “I want to feel the fire that you kept from me,” are potent in their desire for experiencing the intense, the passionate, and the transformative, elements apparently withheld within the relational dynamics.

Why Was “The Moon Will Sing” Written?

To fully grasp the depth of this song, understanding the songwriter’s mindset is pivotal. It seems plausible that “The Moon Will Sing” was penned during a period of reflection, possibly post a tumultuous relationship. The songwriter seems to be exploring and questioning themes of self and identity in relation to another and seems to be in a state of introspection, trying to comprehend the impacts and the residues of choices and relationships on one’s being.

The song portrays a spectrum of emotions and states, ranging from love and light to loss and shadow, possibly reflecting the multifaceted experiences and the diverse emotional landscapes navigated by the songwriter. The recurring celestial imagery and the contrasting elements within, symbolize the eternal and the transient, the visible and the hidden, and the harmonious and the conflicting elements within human interactions and self-discoveries.

It’s conceivable that the song was an attempt to externalize internal conflicts, to voice unspoken pains and unshed tears, and to reach a reconciliation with self and the past. The profound lyrical composition, rich with metaphors and imagery, is seemingly a journey through emotional terrains and philosophical contemplations, offering listeners a glimpse into the human soul and its eternal quest for meaning and connection.