Meaning of “In The Stars” by Benson Boone

Written By Michael Miller

Michael is a music teacher and professional cellist. He loves uncovering the deeper meaning of popular songs.

“In The Stars” by Benson Boone is a poignant ballad expressing loss and heartache. The song portrays the narrator’s grief, detailing the intimate and treasured moments of a relationship, subsequently ending in separation, signified by the metaphor of the other person being ‘in the stars.’ It mirrors Boone’s agony and his struggle with faith in the wake of heartbreak. The juxtaposition of the cherished ‘Sunday mornings’ and his present loneliness intensifies the emotional depth. This song serves as a eulogy, honoring what once was and bemoaning what’s irrevocably lost. It is an ode to the enduring pain, the holding on to ‘everything that’s dead and gone,’ and to love that left the heart in pieces.

The deeper dive into this song is like unfolding layers of emotional turbulence and profoundness. It’s not merely a song; it’s an experience that has the power to echo the concealed pain and lost faith within one’s soul.

If you’ve experienced loss and are intrigued by how Boone beautifully encapsulates this universal human experience, then delve in, and let’s discover the journey together.

“In The Stars” Lyrics Meaning

The song begins with the fond memory of ‘Sunday mornings,’ symbolizing joy and togetherness. These were moments when the other person ‘did [their] hair up like [they] were famous,’ depicting the innocence and joy in mundane activities. The reference to ‘meeting down on Woods Creek Road’ and ‘church’ establishes a setting of simplicity and tradition, grounding the song in a relatable reality. The mention of church also subtly introduces themes of faith and spirituality, which later evolve into a central theme in the song.

However, the joy is transient. ‘Sunday mornings’ now are solitary, highlighted by Boone ‘sleeping in.’ This shift in routine depicts his emotional state, a transformation from a time of shared happiness to solitude and lamentation. The line, ‘It’s like I buried my faith with you,’ is striking, portraying a loss of belief parallel to the loss of the loved one.

The chorus encapsulates the core emotion. Boone is ‘still holding on to everything that’s dead and gone.’ This recurring holding on depicts his struggle to accept and let go. The phrase, ‘in the stars,’ metaphorically places the lost one in a realm untouchable and distant, highlighting the irretrievable nature of the loss, making ‘six-feet’ seem like an immense separation. Here, the narrator is ‘alone between the heavens and the embers,’ symbolizing the struggle between holding on to faith and succumbing to the pain.

The emotional depth is amplified with, ‘Oh, it hurts so hard/For a million different reasons.’ This line is a universal cry, speaking to anyone who’s experienced pain and loss. The ‘crumpled 20 still in the box’ represents unspent, preserved love and memories. Boone’s reluctance to ‘spend it’ signifies his holding on to the remnants of the past, the unwillingness to let go of the emotions associated with it.

Towards the end, the repetition of ‘I’m still holdin’ on’ accentuates Boone’s struggle with acceptance. It conveys the internal battle and the constant loop of pain and memories, making it a universal anthem for enduring love and loss.

Why Was “In The Stars” Written?

Understanding the context in which “In The Stars” was written offers insight into the agony and the intricate emotions embedded in the lyrics. This song appears to emanate from a deeply personal and introspective place, potentially reflecting Boone’s own experiences or observations of loss and the subsequent struggle with faith and acceptance. The intricate blend of personal reflections and universal themes of love and loss suggest a contemplative and empathetic state of mind at the time of writing.

The meticulous portrayal of emotions and intricate details hint at a profound connection to the experience narrated, possibly acting as a cathartic expression for Boone. The song, thus, serves as an echo of collective human experience, resonating with the emotions of those dealing with loss, making it a hauntingly beautiful ode to enduring love and the fragmented pieces it leaves in its wake.